[ ]   [ ]   [ ]                        [ ]      [ ]   [ ]
Wilco — Cruel Country
Album: Cruel Country
Avg rating:
6.5

Your rating:
Total ratings: 434









Released: 2022
Length: 3:19
Plays (last 30 days): 0
I love my country like a little boy
Red, white, and blue

I love my country stupid and cruel
Red, white, and blue

All you have to do is sing in the choir
Kill yourself every once in a while
And sing in the choir
With me

All you have to do is sing in the choir
Set yourself on fire every once in a while
And sing in the choir
With me
With me

I love my country like a little child
Red, white, and blue

I love my country stupid and cruel
Red, white, and blue

All you have to do is sing in the choir
All you have to do is sing in the choir
All you have to do is sing in the choir
With me
With me
Comments (20)add comment

Vapid and simplistic analysis. They seem to show a real lack of understanding of the complexity of American culture or history, especially in comparison to the last 250 or so years of the rest of the world.


Sounds like Jerry
 Ipse_Dixit wrote:

Nice tune. Prinesque in its critique of patriotism, Christianity, and nationalism.

This song is not a critique, it's merely a dismissal. A critique would include some analysis and justification of assertions.

Of course, to those who already think the country, presumably the USA, is "stupid and cruel", justification is unnecessary.

Q: do you think the "love" in "love my country" is true love ('though confounded) or is it just sarcasm?

First time i heard this gave it a 7 because it is wilco
Wilco’d. Rockin!!
Here’s hoping this isn’t the last day left of American democracy, bloody hell.
Just changed my rating from a 7 to an 8 after 3rd rehearsal. I love the Music of Wilco, and Jeff Tweedy is a genius as a songwriter! In 2017 i watched Wilco live at the Haldern Pop Festival in Germany. They played about two hours and it was amazing.
But during their gig nearly half of the audience left the stage! I think the reason was that the Afghan Whigs played before Wilco. It was a mindblowing rock show!
That the organizers of that festival didn´t change the running order, so that Wilco could play before the Afghan Whigs was a mistake for me. But i remember for me that was no Problem ! I enjoyed both of them! 
 QuantumShaman wrote:

Although this is still a relatively new offering from RP and it doesn't have enough ratings to represent an accurate picture yet, I suspect that the low average rating we currently see (6.5) is due to a temporary overbalance of ratings from reactionary, jingoistic, "my country is never wrong!" sorts of people -- the type with the magical ability (cognitive dissonance) to ignore any facts that don't align with the things they want to believe, or to spin those facts into being "lies" in their own heads.  

Most likely, we all do that to at least a slight extent, at least sometimes; but towards the other end of the spectrum you have people who are beholden to a cult and who perform that "magic" on vast swaths of facts and confirmed evidence.  (In the extant case, it may be people seeing the world through Trump-colored glasses.... )

why do we have to label ' a type of people'? this is where we get off track in understanding. people are far more complicated than you present here; with very few exceptions, we are all capapble of all kinds of positive thoughts and actions. dismiss them at your peril.

it's a decent, simple song, fits in the album well. enjoyed seeing them this past year. [still prefer Son Volt, Kazoo!]
Nice tune. Prinesque in its critique of patriotism, Christianity, and nationalism.
Looking forward to seeing Jeff Tweedy on the February Cayamo!
neat tune.
I read a few reviews of this album when it came out that said "country" and "maybe controversial" in different ways. Now I know what they mean I guess. It's got the twang and "country" sound and the lyrics that can be interpreted in different ways. Pushing aside any genre labels or..."patriotism"? this is my first hearing of any song off the album and I like it. A lot maybe. These guys are just good music makers.
it only took them 30 years to get back to the uncle tupelo sound
 QuantumShaman wrote:

Although this is still a relatively new offering from RP and it doesn't have enough ratings to represent an accurate picture yet, I suspect that the low average rating we currently see (6.5) is due to a temporary overbalance of ratings from reactionary, jingoistic, "my country is never wrong!" sorts of people -- the type with the magical ability (cognitive dissonance) to ignore any facts that don't align with the things they want to believe, or to spin those facts into being "lies" in their own heads.  

Most likely, we all do that to at least a slight extent, at least sometimes; but towards the other end of the spectrum you have people who are beholden to a cult and who perform that "magic" on vast swaths of facts and confirmed evidence.  (In the extant case, it may be people seeing the world through Trump-colored glasses.... )


Don't make the perfect the enemy of the good.
Although this is still a relatively new offering from RP and it doesn't have enough ratings to represent an accurate picture yet, I suspect that the low average rating we currently see (6.5) is due to a temporary overbalance of ratings from reactionary, jingoistic, "my country is never wrong!" sorts of people -- the type with the magical ability (cognitive dissonance) to ignore any facts that don't align with the things they want to believe, or to spin those facts into being "lies" in their own heads.  

Most likely, we all do that to at least a slight extent, at least sometimes; but towards the other end of the spectrum you have people who are beholden to a cult and who perform that "magic" on vast swaths of facts and confirmed evidence.  (In the extant case, it may be people seeing the world through Trump-colored glasses.... )
Wow.

c.
 idiot_wind wrote:

Hey Bill,  

You gots lot of pull with these here musicians. 

Can you tell these guys do do some touring in Summer 2022? Preferably in the Midwest.  Their freakin home!


   




Is Indiana good enough for you?
Granted! https://www.songkick.com/conce...
Hey Bill,  

You gots lot of pull with these here musicians. 

Can you tell these guys do do some touring in Summer 2022? Preferably in the Midwest.  Their freakin home!


   
New Wilco music! 
Bill mentioned in the lead-in to this song the album includes 21 songs. This, in addition to all of the music Jeff writes for his solo projects. Wow.

He wrote a book, How To Write One Song, I received as a Christmas gift last year. I think I need to read it and see what his secret is.
!